Can you monetize Hailuo (MiniMax)’s free tier?

Reproduce it yourself: each factor's risk points = weight × level ÷ 4 (an unclear factor counts as half its weight). The seven add up to 60. Every scored factor quotes Hailuo (MiniMax)’s own current terms, pricing or help page.

1. Commercial-use rights

   Level 3/421 / 28 pts

   Does the license actually permit monetizing the free-tier output (monetized video / paid client deliverable)? The single most decisive factor.

   “These Terms of Use permit you to use the Services for your personal, non-commercial use only.”

   The main Terms of Service restrict ALL use of the Services to 'personal, non-commercial use only' and add: 'You must not access or use for any commercial purposes any part of the Services.' Commercial rights are granted ONLY on a paid plan — the Subscription Service Terms say: 'We do not claim ownership over content you generate and download while on a paid subscription plan ... you retain any and all intellectual property rights to such content, including the right to use it for commercial purposes.' That grant is scoped to paid users, so a free-tier creator monetizing video is outside the license. Because it is trivially unlocked on the cheap Standard tier ($14.99/mo), this is L3 (not L4). Decisive factor.

2. Free-plan monetization gate

   Level 3/413.5 / 18 pts

   Free-tier blockers that make output unusable even when commercial use is allowed: watermark, 'personal-only' wording, publish-barring caps.

   “Free Users : Video downloads will include a watermark.”

   Visible watermark burned onto every free export, removable only by upgrading: 'Paid Users : Standard plan subscribers and higher-tier users will be able to download videos without a watermark.' Classic L3 visible-watermark gate, removable only by paying.

3. Output ownership & sublicensing

   Level 3/412 / 16 pts

   Do you own (or get a clean, transferable, sublicensable license to) the output? Decisive for agency/client work where rights must be handed over.

   “By using the Services, you grant to us, our affiliates, successors, and assigns a royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable, worldwide, non-exclusive right (including any moral rights) and license to use, license, reproduce, modify, adapt, publish, translate, create derivative works from, distribute, derive revenue or other remuneration from, and communicate to the public, perform and display your User Contributions and User Generated Content (in whole or in part) worldwide”

   Although the tool disclaims ownership, the platform retains a perpetual, irrevocable license that explicitly lets it 'derive revenue or other remuneration from' your generated content, and 'This license survives termination of this Agreement by any party, for any reason.' That is a broad tool-retained right (L3) that persists on paid tiers too, which is why scorePaid keeps ownership at L3.

4. Attribution / branding obligation

   Level 0/40 / 12 pts

   Must you credit the tool, keep a logo, or disclose it by name? An enforceable monetization burden even when commercial use is allowed.

   “These Terms of Use permit you to use the Services for your personal, non-commercial use only.”

   Neither the Terms of Service nor the Subscription Service Terms impose any textual attribution, on-screen credit, or 'made with Hailuo' tagging obligation. The only branding artifact is the free-tier download watermark, which is fully captured under freeGate L3 — counting it here too would double-count the same artifact. There is no distinct credit obligation, so attribution = L0. (Quote shown is the primary-source page confirming no credit clause exists; the watermark itself is scored once, under freeGate.)

5. Copyright & training-data exposure

   Level 2/46 / 12 pts

   Risk the output infringes third-party rights or triggers a platform claim: training-data provenance, indemnity, likeness/voice-clone consent, YouTube synthetic-content exposure.

   “you, not the Company, have full responsibility for such content, including its legality, reliability, accuracy, and appropriateness.”

   Standard generative text/image-to-video with no licensed-data indemnity; all legality liability is pushed onto the user, and MiniMax/Hailuo synthetic video output triggers YouTube's synthetic-media disclosure. No forced realistic-person/voice-clone consent regime, and the disclosure itself does not cut monetization, so L2 (not L3).

6. Terms stability

   Level 2/44 / 8 pts

   How likely are today's rights to be quietly changed or revoked tomorrow? Modification clause, retroactivity, notice, and observed change history. The factor the ToS-monitor sells against.

   “We reserve the right to modify, replace, and/or update this Agreement at any time.”

   Broad unilateral right to modify/replace 'at any time' with no stated notice commitment, reinforced in the ToS: 'All changes are effective immediately when we post them.' That is L2 (broad unilateral, no notice). No documented retroactive or adverse change in the last 12 months, so not L3/L4.

7. Creator practicality

   Level 2/43 / 6 pts

   The gap between 'technically licensed' and 'actually usable safely': terms clarity/findability, login-gated pricing, credit-model traps. Modulates, never decides.

   “Standard Plan: Priced at $14.99 per month, this plan includes accelerated video generation (queue priority), watermark-free downloads, and 1,000 credits per month.”

   Terms and the subscription-terms price table are public plain text, but the live /pricing, /subscribe and /membership pages are JS-gated and return no static prices, and a marketed '$7.99/mo' promo (third-party reported) diverges from the documented $14.99 Standard price — pricing requires login/JS to confirm and marketing diverges from terms (L2). Confirm exact charged price at checkout.

ClipJury's monetization-risk verdicts are an editorial read of each tool's own current public terms and pricing as of the last-checked date — not legal advice. Terms change; always confirm against the linked sources before relying on any tool for monetized or paid client work. How we score risk →